A person at a dining table filling a black plastic cell tray with damp seed-starting mix from a tub, seed packets beside it

Seed Starting Mix for Tomatoes and Peppers: Buy It or Make It

For indoor tomato and pepper starts, choose a light mix that drains well. Miracle-Gro’s ready-to-use seed-starting mix is a simple first choice.

Miracle-Gro estimates one 8 qt bag fills about three 72-cell trays, which lets you count trays before you buy.

Amazon links here are affiliate links: buy through one and the site earns a small commission, with nothing added to your price.

The five mixes, at a glance:

Miracle-Gro Indoor Potting Mix for Seed Starting, 8 qt, 2-pack

A first tray of tomato and pepper seeds, with no mixing to do.

Miracle-Gro Seed Starting Potting Mix, 8 qt, 2-Pack Miracle-Gro Seed Starting Potting Mix, 8 qt, 2-Pack Ready to use in cell trays One bag fills about three 72-cell trays Check the Amazon price

The mix is enriched with plant food. It contains neither compost nor bark.

On that figure, the 2-pack fills about six 72-cell trays. Exact amounts may vary.

Works well for
A bag size you can turn into a tray count
Not needed if
One small tray of seeds (the pack is two 8 qt bags)

Hoffman Seed Starter Potting & Planting Mix, 10 qt

Seeds in trays or cells where the mix needs to take up water.

Hoffman Seed Starter Mix with Wetting Agent, 10 qt Hoffman Seed Starter Mix with Wetting Agent, 10 qt Soilless mix, six components Wetting agent for moisture retention Check the Amazon price

This is a light, loose, fertile soilless mix for germination, with a wetting agent (an additive that helps a mix soak up water).

It is also sold for transplanting and root cuttings, so leftover mix has a second use once the seedlings are up.

Works well for
A mix that also suits transplanting and root cuttings

Burpee Organic Coconut Coir Seed Starting Mix, 16 qt

A peat-free mix that stores dry and compact until you are ready to sow.

Burpee Organic Coconut Coir Seed Starting Mix, 16 qt Burpee Organic Coconut Coir Seed Starting Mix, 16 qt Coir (coconut husk fiber) bricks Each brick expands into 8 quarts Check the Amazon price

The coir is a renewable alternative to peat moss, made from recycled coconut husks.

Each brick expands into 8 quarts of mix once water is added, which makes 16 quarts in total. The bricks take up little space until planting day.

Jiffy Natural & Organic Seed Starting Mix, 10 qt

A plain three-ingredient mix with a short ingredient list you can read at a glance.

Jiffy Natural & Organic Seed Starting Mix, 10 qt Jiffy Natural & Organic Seed Starting Mix, 10 qt Peat moss, vermiculite and lime 10 qt bag Check the Amazon price

The mix is peat moss, vermiculite and lime. Vermiculite (a moisture-holding additive) helps prevent compaction.

The lime is there to balance pH, which is how acidic the mix is.

Purple Cow Seed Starter Mix, 12 qt

Seedlings you want to start in a compost-based mix.

Purple Cow Seed Starter Mix, 12 qt Purple Cow Seed Starter Mix, 12 qt Compost-based mix Ready to use Check the Amazon price

The mix is made with Purple Cow’s activated compost.

Purple Cow estimates the mix can feed seedlings for up to 45 days.

Works well for
Compost-based mix with feed already in it

Seed mix and potting mix are not the same

Seed mix has a finer texture, and garden soil is too dense for a tray.

Fine-textured mixes are especially useful for sowing tiny seeds. Garden soil can pack tightly in a cell tray and restrict drainage and airflow.

Wet the mix before it goes into the cells

Moisten the mix first, until it feels like a wrung-out sponge. Thoroughly moisten dry media before filling pots. That matters most if it contains peat moss, as most potting mixes do.

After sowing, Miracle-Gro says to keep the mix moist and out of direct sunlight until germination.

Why seeds fail in the wrong mix

Young tomato seedlings with their first leaves standing upright in a cell tray on a windowsill

Damping off, the disease that rots seedling roots, takes hold when the mix stays wet. Several soilborne organisms can cause it.

A poorly drained tray can lose its seedlings quickly.

Oregon State also warns that backyard soil is compacted, full of weed seeds and not pasteurized, which can lead to seedling diseases.

To reduce the risk, use a well-drained mix and avoid overwatering. Allow the top of the growing mix to dry slightly before watering. Soilless potting media are also recommended for growing transplants.

Buy it or make it

A bag of seed mix saves the pasteurizing step; the homemade recipe needs it. Oregon State’s recipe is three equal parts:

  • One-third pasteurized soil or compost.
  • One-third sand, vermiculite or perlite.
  • One-third coconut coir or peat moss.

Pasteurizing means heating the soil or compost so it is free of pests and diseases. Oregon State says to keep the mix at 180°F for 30 minutes. It warns that overheating can damage the soil structure.

Your pots and spaceStart with this
A first tray of tomatoes and peppers, no mixingMiracle-Gro Indoor Potting Mix for Seed Starting, 8 qt, 2-pack
Seeds in trays, with a wetting agent in the mixHoffman Seed Starter Potting & Planting Mix, 10 qt
A peat-free mix stored dry until sowingBurpee Organic Coconut Coir Seed Starting Mix, 16 qt
A short peat, vermiculite and lime mixJiffy Natural & Organic Seed Starting Mix, 10 qt
Compost-based mix with nutrients includedPurple Cow Seed Starter Mix, 12 qt
An oven, a pasteurized base and time to mix a batchHomemade mix (Oregon State recipe)

Which way to go for a first tray

For a first tray, buy a bag. When the tray is filled, a seed-starting schedule by frost date shows when to sow by counting back from your last frost.

The mix for the final pot is a different product. What makes a good potting mix for containers covers its ingredients and reusing it.

Keep the homemade recipe for a year when you already have a pasteurized base.

Scroll to Top
Pits In Pieces
Privacy Overview

This website uses cookies so that we can provide you with the best user experience possible. Cookie information is stored in your browser and performs functions such as recognising you when you return to our website and helping our team to understand which sections of the website you find most interesting and useful.